Revista de la Facultad de Ciencias Agrarias. Universidad Nacional de Cuyo. Tomo 55(2). ISSN (en línea) 1853-8665. Año 2023.

Original article

Effect of cutting height, a bacterial inoculant and a fibrolytic enzyme on corn (Zea mays L.) silage quality

Altura de corte y adición de un inoculante bacteriano y una enzima fibrolítica sobre la calidad del ensilado de maíz (Zea mays L.)

Sergio Ramírez Ordóñes ¹^*

José A. Rueda ²

Carlos Iván Medel Contreras ²

Jorge Hernández Bautista ³

Agustín Corral Luna ¹

Monserrath Félix Portillo ¹

¹ Universidad Autónoma de Chihuahua. Facultad de Zootecnia y Ecología. Periférico Francisco R. Almada km 1. Chihuahua. Chihuahua. 33820. México.

² Universidad del Papaloapan. Instituto de Agroingeniería. Av. Ferrocarril SN. Loma Bonita. Oaxaca. 68400. México.

³ Universidad Autónoma Benito Juárez de Oaxaca. Facultad de Medicina Veterinaria y Zootecnia. Oaxaca. 68110. México.

^*mvzsramirez@gmail.com

Abstract

This study aimed to evaluate cutting height (CH) effects on ensiled corn without additives (C), with a lactic acid bacteria inoculant (L), a fibrolytic enzyme (F), or a mixture of both (FL), considering chemical composition and both in vitro digestibility dry matter (IVDMD) and in vitro neutral detergent fiber (IVNDFD). Corn was harvested at three different cutting heights (12, 25 or 42 cm above the soil) and ensiled with or without additives (AD). Data was analyzed according to a factorial design, with a 3 x 4 arrangement of treatments and three repeats. Dry matter content was highest in C12 and lowest in F12 (P<0.05) silages. As cutting height was higher, cell wall content was lower (P<0.05). Even considering it increased after the use of additives (P<0.05), the highest values occurred with FL silages. Crude protein was equal (P˃0.05) between CH and increased (P<0.05) with AD. The highest IVDMD was observed for 42 cm CH, while IVDMD and IVNDFD were higher in C and F, but lower with FL. None of the inoculation treatments, alone or combined improved corn silage quality. In fact, FL combination decreased such quality.

Keywords: additives, starch, biomass, soluble carbohydrates, NDFD, digestibility, fiber

Resumen

El objetivo de este estudio fue evaluar el efecto de la altura de corte (AC) sobre la composición química y la digestibilidad in vitro tanto de la materia seca (DIVMS) como de la fibra detergente neutro (DIVFDN) de plantas de maíz ensiladas sin (C), con inoculante de bacterias ácidos lácticas (L), una enzima fibrolítica (F), o una mezcla de ambos (FL). El maíz fue cosechado a tres alturas de corte (12, 25 y 42 cm por encima de suelo) y ensilado con o sin aditivos (AD). Los datos se analizaron de acuerdo con un diseño con arreglo factorial 3 x 4 con tres repeticiones. El contenido de materia seca en los ensilados fue más alto en C12 y más bajo en F12 (P<0,05). A mayor altura de corte, la fracción de la pared celular fue menor (P<0,05), aunque con el uso de aditivos, esta aumentó (P<0,05); los valores más altos ocurrieron con FL. La proteína cruda fue igual (P˃0,05) entre AC y se incrementó (P<0,05) con AD. La DIVMS más alta se observó en la altura de 42 cm AC, mientras que la DIVMS y DIVFDN fueron más altas con C y F y más bajas con FL. Ningún aditivo, solo o en combinación, mejoró la calidad del ensilado de maíz; de hecho, la combinación FL disminuyó dicha calidad.

Palabras clave: aditivos, almidón, biomasa, carbohidratos solubles, DFDN, digestibilidad, fibra

Originales: Recepción: 25/11/2021 - Aceptación: 31/07/2023

Introduction

Feeding corn silage to dairy cows is a growing practice in the Mexican tropics. Maximizing nutrient bioavailability of corn silage would represent important economic and productive advantages. Specifically, enhancing cell wall degradability might improve profits while reducing both solid excretion and methane production, and potentially reducing grain level in feed up to 3% (⁴⁰).

Plant cell walls are a major source of energy for ruminants. However, only less than 50% are readily digested and utilized by the ruminant host (³). In fact, the low degradability of cell wall fractions (cellulose, hemicellulose, pectin and lignin) is a key factor limiting its use by rumen microorganisms. In addition to corn variety, crop maturity, kernel processing and particle cut length (¹²), another alternative to improve fiber degradability of corn silage is to increase cutting height at harvest (⁹) improving both forage quality and milk production (^{9, 12, 21}).

Lactic acid bacteria (LAB) inoculants and exogenous fibrolytic enzymes (EFE) have become popular as silage additives intended to improve silage nutritional value (^{5, 17, 26}). LAB improve fermentation characteristics by promoting faster pH decline, avoiding both proteolysis and excessive fermentation of water-soluble carbohydrates (WSC) (²⁵). In addition, LAB also improve the lactic acid-acetic acid ratio and promote low ammonia nitrogen content (³⁸). Furthermore, dry matter loss is reduced by 35%, while intake, digestibility, weight gain, and milk production are also improved (³⁸). Exogenous fibrolytic enzymes promote cellulose and hemicellulose hydrolysis, therefore improving cell wall degradation while releasing WSC, which undergoes subsequent fermentation by LAB (^{15, 33}). Additionally, the enzymatic additives improve fermentation by stimulating the production of acids and lowering pH and ammonia nitrogen in the silage (³⁸). When EFE are added to forage, parameters like digestibility, dry matter intake and milk production, usually increase (³⁸). However, data on how EFE affects digestibility of DM and NDF have been mostly inconsistent (^{17, 38}).

Among other factors, LAB efficacy depends on WSC content of the forage to be ensiled, while EFE extent of action is related to both NDF content and chemical composition. It is hypothesized that changing the grain-to-stover ratio through cutting height might promote the synergistic effect between LAB and EFE on silage digestibility. This study aimed to assess the single and combined effects of LAB and/or EFE on chemical composition and in vitro digestibility of the DM and NDF in corn silage when corn is harvested at different cutting heights.

Materials and methods

Corn was planted in Jose Azueta, Veracruz, Mexico; at 18°05’50” N and 95°39’35’’ W, and 16 m above sea level. Local climate is warm and subhumid with summer rains (Aw1). Maximum, mean and minimum temperatures are 31.8, 26.3 and 20.8°C, with an annual rainfall of 1601 mm (¹⁶). The most common soil types are gleysol (39%) and phaeozem (39%).

Hybrid corn DK-357 (DEKALB®) was established on November 29 of 2017, and grown under rainfed conditions. Sowing density was 75,000 seeds ha^-1, at 80 cm between rows. Fertilization consisted of 175 kg ha-1 of diammonium phosphate (DAP, 18-46-00) during sowing.

Treatments and silages

Corn was harvested when dry matter content approached 35%, around day 103 after planting. On the plot, ten out of 108 rows were randomly selected and three 10 m long sections were sampled at 20, 150 and 280 m from the end row. On every sampling, plant number and height, stem diameter and node number were recorded. Then, six random plants were cut at 12, 25 or 42 cm cutting heights (CH). A total of 60 plants were harvested for every CH. Plants were then transported to the Laboratory of the Universidad del Papaloapan, in Loma Bonita, Oaxaca.

Fifty-five out of the 60 plants, were assigned to four treatments: without additive (C, control) and with additives (AD) Fibrozyme® (F), Sil-All® (L), and with Fibrozyme plus Sil-All (FL). According to manufacturers, Fibrozyme® (Alltech Inc., Nicholasville, KY, USA) is a fermentation extract of Aspergillus niger and Trichoderma viride with 31.0 and 43.4 IU of xylanase and cellulase activity, respectively (11). Sil-All® (Lallemand Specialties, Inc. Milwaukee, WI, USA) contains Lactobacillus plantarum, Pediococcus acidilactici, Enterococcus faecium, Lactobacillus salivarius at a minimum ratio of 2.1 x 1010 CFU g^-1.

Plants were cut with a stationary gas chopper (Raiken® RKP-3000B) before filling three laboratory silos with their corresponding treatment (C12, C25, C42, F12, F25, F42, L12, L25, L42 or FL12, FL25, FL42). Laboratory silos with a capacity of 3.0 kg of fresh forage, were made from PVC tubes (15.7” high x 4” wide). Sil-All dosage was provided according to manufacturer’s specifications (10 mg kg^-1 of fresh forage). Fibrozyme dosage was 60 mg kg^-1 of the DM to be ensiled. Twenty-two milliliters of distilled water dissolved each additive, and then the solution was spread over the chopped forage. Treatment C consisted of 22 mL of distilled water spread over the forage. Then, laboratory silos were filled up and compacted manually, covered with a grow bag and sealed with brown tape. The 36 laboratory silos were weighted and kept at room temperature in the Laboratory of the Universidad del Papaloapan for 50 days.

Chemical analysis

After 50 d of ensiling, all laboratory silos were weighted and then opened. Considering each silo, pH was assessed in a 25 g sample mixed in 250 mL of distilled water and blended for 30 s at maximum speed. The solution was filtered through two cheesecloth layers before taking the pH readings with a HANNA® potentiometer (model pH 209, Instruments Inc. USA).

Partial dry matter content was determined with 500 g samples from each silo, oven dried at 60°C for 48 h and ground through a Wiley® mill to pass a 1 mm screen (¹⁰). Ground samples were used to estimate total dry matter (method # 930.15), ash (method # 942.05) and crude protein content (CP, method # 990.03), according to AOAC (2006). Furthermore, cell wall fractions of neutral detergent fiber (NDF), acid detergent fiber (ADF), and acid detergent lignin (ADL) were determined. The NDF analysis was carried out using Na₂SO₃ and α-amylase. ADL analysis was run in a beaker by immersion in 72% H₂SO₄. Cell-wall fractions content was determined sequentially in the ANKOM200® fiber analyzer, using Ankom F57® filter bags, following the procedures proposed by the company. Additionally, non-fibrous carbohydrates (NFC) content was calculated using the equation: NFC (%) = 100 – [NDF% + CP% + ether extract % + ash], where NDF was not corrected for CP or ash, and ether extract was considered 3.2% for all silages (²⁸).

In vitro digestibility of DM and NDF

In vitro DM digestibility (IVDMD) and NDF (IVNDFD) were determined by incubating silage samples in Ankom F57® filter bags for 48 h in a DAYSI-II® incubator, as recommended by the manufacturer. Ruminal inoculum was collected from three slaughtered cows in the Loma Bonita slaughterhouse. Donors grazed tropical pastures.

Total digestible nutrients per hectare (TDN ha-1) was calculated through the equation: %TDN = 87.84 - (0.70 x ADF) (³⁶) and multiplying those values in silages by dry matter yield (DMY) obtained at each cutting height.

Statistical analyses

Data were analyzed for effects of AD, CH and CH x AD using a general linear model (³¹) as a completely randomized design in a 4 x 3 factorial arrangement with three repeats per treatment: one control (C), three treatments including additive and/or enzyme (F, L and FL) and three CH (12, 25 and 42 cm). Mean comparison was run by least significant difference (LSD), at P≤0.05. Additionally, cell wall fractions and forage yield in response to CH were analyzed by regression analysis.

Results and discussion

Dry matter content

Significant differences in DM content of corn silage were found for the interaction CH x AD (P=0.01). At 12 cm cutting height, C12 (control treatment) showed the highest (P<0.05) and F12 showed the lowest (P<0.05) DM content, with 33.9, 31.2, 30.1 and 28.9% for C12, FL12, L12 and F12, respectively, while for 25 and 42 cm cutting heights, no differences were found (figure 1).

For each cutting height bars with different letter are statistically different (P<0.05). C - control (distilled water only); F - Fibrozyme® (fibrolytic enzymes with xylanase activity); L - Sil-All® (bacterial inoculant for silage based on lactic acid bacteria); FL - mixture of Fibrozyme + Sil-All.

Para cada altura de corte barras con diferente letra son estadísticamente diferentes (P<0,05). C- control (solo agua destilada); F - Fibrozyme® (enzimas fibrolíticas con actividad xilanasa); L - Sil-All® (inoculante bacteriano para ensilaje a base de bacterias ácido-lácticas); FL - mezcla de Fibrozyme + Sil-All.

Figure 1. Dry matter (%) of corn silage in response to additive (C, F, L, FL) and cutting height (12, 25, 42 cm).

Figura 1. Materia seca (%) de ensilados de maíz en respuesta al aditivo (C, F, L, FL) y a la altura de corte (12, 25, 42 cm).

Harvesting at higher CH implied an improvement of digestible nutrients per kilogram of DM, then reflected in milk yield, both per area and weight unit. These improvements justify leaving the most fibrous and lignified part of the stem on the field. On the other hand, an increase of 1.7 units (5.2%) in DM content is expected with the increase in CH from 12 to 42 cm, due to higher DM content in cobs compared to leaves or stems (²³). In this regard, higher CH results in increased DM content in corn crops for ensiling, explained by a higher stover-to-grain ratio in the ensiled mass (¹⁸). Regarding AD, Colombatto et al. (2004) found no effect of added EFE on corn silage DM, with 33.3 and 33.8% average fresh and ensiled corn, respectively.

Dry matter yield (DMY) due to cutting height effect

Average DMY was 10.7 t ha^-1. At conventional CH (12 cm) DMY was low (12.5 t ha^-1), given three factors: final plant density (52,430 plants ha-1), plant height (198.3 cm) and rainfall, considering water availability is a determining factor in forage yield (³⁰). As expected, DMY was highest (P<0.0001) for the 12 cm as compared to 25 cm and 42 cm CH (figure 2).

Figure 2. Dry matter yield (t ha-1) of the whole corn plant harvested at three cutting heights (CH).

Figura 2. Rendimiento de materia seca (t ha-1) de la planta entera de maíz cosechada a tres alturas de corte.

DMY decreases as CH increases, because of the lower proportion of stem in plants harvested at a greater height. On the other hand, DMY is also affected by DM content of the harvested forage, which might vary among different CH (figure 1, page 132). Both forage DM and forage moisture content, are also related to the amount of stem left on the field at each CH. That is, the higher the CH at harvest (such as 25 cm and 42 cm) the lower the amount of moisture carried within the plant, which in the end is reflected in a higher DM content, since the stem contributes the most to plant moisture (^21,
40).

DMY is inversely proportional to cutting height. In this study, the greater reduction in DMY occurred between 12 and 25 cm (20.1%) CH; followed by 25 to 42 cm (15.1%); while for CH 12 to 42 cm, DMY was considerably higher (37.3%). The regression analysis showed that for every 1 cm increase in CH above 12 cm, DMY decreases 112 kg ha^-1 (R2=0.51; P<0.05). The 37.3% decrease in DMY from 12 to 42 cm is significantly high compared to results published by other research groups. For instance, Wu and Roth (2005) reported a 7.4% reduction in DMY when the CH changed from 17 to 48 cm; Kung et al. (2008) found a DMY drop of 20.1% from 10-15 to 46-51 cm, and Neylon and Kung (2003) reported decreases of 5 to 10% DMY when CH went from 12.7 to 45.7 cm. These reported DMY dissimilarities might be explained by the differences in plant heights among them. For example, Kung et al. (2008) reported an average plant height of 3.04 m, while in the present study, average was 1.98 m. Plant height must be considered before deciding on harvest cutting height.

Chemical composition

pH ranged from 3.86 to 4.43, with an average pH of 4.0, suggesting all silages were well preserved. Silage pH was not affected by the added fibrolytic enzyme, bacterial inoculant or cutting height. The purpose of adding an inoculant or enzyme was to improve forage fermentation by stimulating organic acids production and thus lowering pH (³⁶). However, the addition of L, F or their combination did not stimulate fermentation of WSC due to EFE effect, since final pH remained unaffected, as in previous studies (^{6, 8}).

The activity of most EFE improves when pH is above 4.5 (^{2, 38}). It has been suggested that EFE work better at a ruminal pH close to neutrality (⁸). Neylon and Kung (2003), did not find pH changes between corn cutting heights at 12.7 or 45.7 cm, at 34% of DM. Usually, when adding an inoculant, studies focus both on pH and acid concentration (^{9, 24}); given the speed at which pH falls and stops enzymatic and bacterial activity plays a key role in avoiding unnecessary nutrient loss. However, in this work pH was not measured at different times. Crude protein (CP) in silages was higher (P<0.01) with L, F or the combination LF, as compared to the control (table 1), registering an increase of 0.4 to 0.8 %.

Table 1. Crude protein (CP, % of DM) and in vitro digestibility of corn silages harvested at three cutting heights (in cm) and inoculated with lactic acid bacteria and exogenous fibrolytic enzymes.

Tabla 1. Proteína cruda (PC, % de la MS) y digestibilidad in vitro de ensilados de maíz cosechados a tres alturas de corte (en cm) e inoculados con bacterias ácido lácticas y enzimas fibrolíticas exógenas.

^ab For each factor, different letters indicate statistical differences (P≤0.05). ¹ SEM - Standard error mean; ² CP - crude protein; ³ IVDMD - in vitro dry matter digestibility, after 48 h of incubation in the DaisyII equipment; ⁴ IVNDFD - in vitro neutral detergent fiber digestibility, after 48 h of incubation in the DaisyII equipment; C - control (distilled water); F - Fibrozyme® (fibrolytic enzymes with xylanase activity); L - Sil-All® (bacterial inoculant for silage based on lactic acid bacteria); FL - mixture of Fibrozyme + Sil-All. ^* - a trend.

^ab Para cada factor, diferentes letras indican diferencia estadística (P≤0.05); ¹ SEM - Error estándar de la media; ² CP - proteína cruda; ³ IVDMD - digestibilidad in vitro de la materia seca, después de 48 h de incubación en el equipo DaisyII; ⁴ IVNDFD - digestibilidad in vitro de la fibra detergente neutro, después de 48 h de incubación en el equipo DaisyII; C - control (solo agua destilada); F - Fibrozyme® (enzimas fibrolíticas con actividad xilanasa); L - Sil-All® (inoculante bacteriano para ensilado a base de bacterias ácido lácticas); FL - mezcla de Fibrozyme + Sil-All. ^* - una tendencia.

Thus, as previously documented, we assume less proteolysis when these additives are used (^{14, 35}). Bacterial inoculants promote faster pH decline in silage with the consequent prevention of more WSC consumption, as well as further proteolysis.

The lower CP content recorded in the control (C) may be related to higher (P<0.05) DM content (32.6, 30.9, 31.4 and 32%) and less DM loss (P<0.05) during fermentation in these silages (0.97, 2.97, 1.85 and 1.87% for C, F, L, and FL, respectively), causing CP dilution. This is also supported by the fact that the treated silage showed lower quality, evidenced by a higher fiber content and a lower digestibility than C silages. Besides, it has been widely stated that protein content in corn silages is not affected by CH at harvest (^{19, 22, 38}). Finally, average CP content was 7.9%, within the expected range according to NRC (2001).

Cell-wall fractions. The NDF, ADF, hemicellulose, cellulose and ADL, as well as non-fiber carbohydrates (NFC), showed interaction effects (P<0.01). The lower cell wall and higher NFC content occurred in C42 silage (table 2).

Table 2. Cell wall fractions (% of DM) in corn silages harvested at three cutting heights and inoculated with lactic acid bacteria and exogenous fibrolytic enzymes.

Tabla 2. Fracciones de la pared celular (% de la MS) de ensilados de maíz cosechados a tres alturas de corte e inoculados con bacterias ácido lácticas y enzimas fibrolíticas.

For each cutting height means with different letters are statistically different (P≤0.05). SEM ¹- Standard error mean; ² NDF - neutral detergent fiber; ³ ADF - acid detergent fiber; ⁴ ADL - acid detergent lignin; 5 NFC - non-fiber carbohydrates [100 - (NDF + CP + ether extract + ash)]; C - control (distilled water); F - Fibrozyme® (fibrolytic enzymes with xylanase activity); L - Sil-All® (bacterial inoculant for silage based on lactic acid bacteria); FL - mixture of Fibrozyme + Sil-All.

Para cada altura de corte, medias con diferente letra son estadísticamente diferentes (P≤0,05). ¹ SEM - Error estándar de la media; ² NDF - fibra detergente neutro; ³ ADF - fibra detergente ácido; ⁴ ADL- lignina detergente ácido; 5 NFC - carbohidratos no fibrosos [100- (PC + cenizas + grasa cruda + FDN)]; C - control (solo agua destilada); F - Fibrozyme® (enzimas fibrolíticas con actividad xilanasa); L - Sil-All® (inoculante bacteriano para ensilado a base de bacterias ácido lácticas); FL - mezcla de Fibrozyme + Sil-All.

Conversely, the highest cell wall and the lowest NFC contents converged in FL12 silage. In fact, all FL silages showed higher cell walls and lower NFC contents as compared to the remaining treatments (P<0.05). Higher fiber values in FL silages could be consequence of a dilution effect due to a greater loss of WSC occurring in this treatment (^{15, 17}). At the CH of 12 cm, hemicellulose and ADL content were lower for the F silages, as compared to C silages, whereas, ADL values of the L silages (P<0.05) were lower than those of the C silages. Cell wall content was affected by cutting height (P<0.05) i.e., the higher cutting height had the lower cell wall content. The latter remained true for the treatments without additives (P=0.05) (table 2).

In this research, both additives combined resulted in a setback regarding the expected reduction in cell wall fractions. Noteworthy is that EFE activity depends on several factors (type of enzyme, type of forage, pH, temperature, dosage, and others), and if most of these conditions are met, greater enzymatic efficacy may be achieved upon the potentially digestible fraction of the forages.

The NDF, ADF and ADL contents were within the range stated by the NRC (2001) for corn silages with 32 to 38% DM. However, our values were slightly higher than those reported in previous studies (^{6, 22, 24, 40}). Such discrepancies might be explained by environmental differences as is widely known that grasses accumulate more cell walls when grown in warmer climates, such as those from intertropical regions (⁴), as might be the case for the corn genotype herein considered.

In this study, the use of fibrolytic enzyme negatively impacted silage fiber content and digestibility, probably a consequence of the high xylanase activity presented in the used EFE. It has been observed that enzymes with xylanase activity do not improve DM or NDF biodegradability (¹¹). In contrast, an improvement in NDF degradation occured when EFE had higher endoglucanase activity (^{11, 33}). In this regard, Wallace et al. (2001) reported that several products with endoglucanase activity were more effective at stimulating fermentation in corn silage than those with high xylanase activity and low endoglucanase activity.

Finally, Vallejo et al. (2016) concluded that cellulases were more effective than xylanases when added to corn straws. Unlike ferulic acid esterase, xylanase and cellulase cannot hydrolyze the ester bonds between sugars and hydroxycinnamic acids within the cell wall (²). On the other hand, according to the manufacturer the Fibrozyme is recommended for TMR and not for ensiled forage. In this regard, Singh et al. (2018) found that xylanases and cellulases are more effective in TMR than applied on concentrate or forage. Furthermore, LAB are more effective in grasses with lower WSC and low buffering capacity than in forages like corn, sorghum or sugar cane (²⁹). Lastly, LAB do not have a direct influence on forage DM digestibility, but they can promote better silage fermentation.

In vitro DM and NDF digestibility

The IVDMD was affected by both additives and cutting height, while IVNDFD showed a trend (P=0.06) by additive effect (table 1, page 134). Both IVDMD and IVNDFD, were higher in C and F and lower in FL silages (P<0.05). In this study, IVDMD and IVNDFD followed a similar pattern as compared to cell wall content (table 2, page 135). The highest digestibility occurred for C silages, where fiber was lower, whereas the opposite occurred for FL silages. Regarding cutting height, IVDMD was higher (P<0.05) for 42 cm (77.7%). IVNDFD was unaltered by cutting height (P=0.15); however, the 42 cm treatment exceeded that of 12 cm by 2.2% (table 1, page 134).

The highest and lowest IVDMD observed in C and FL respectively, might be related to the lowest (0.97%) and highest (2.97%) DM losses during fermentation. Consequently, less degradable fibrous components increased, either by dilution or by the greater degradation of WSC when additives are used. However, this last hypothesis is weakly supported since pH was not lower. On the other hand, it is also possible that LAB did not use WSC effectively. Sheperd and Kung (1996) observed that after 56 d of fermentation, pH was equal (3.55) for silage treated with EFE compared to untreated, where glucose content represented 0.10 and 0.37% of DM (P<0.05), respectively; suggesting that cell walls were partially hydrolyzed by added enzymes. On the other hand, after 196 d of fermentation with and without EFE, pH was 3.63 and 3.56 (P<0.05) and glucose percentages were 0.09 and 0.10%, respectively. Increases in IVDMD by varying cutting height from 12 to 42 cm, accorded with many studies showing that varying cutting height at harvest implies improvements (^{12, 27}) in corn silage digestibility of about 2.5 and 4.7% for IVDMD and IVNDFD, respectively (⁴⁰).

Corn silage nutritional value could not be improved by EFE, LAB or their combination, since IVDMD and IVNDFD at 48 h of incubation were lower than in the control treatment. Previous studies reported similar effects of EFE on silage (^{19, 24, 32}); while other studies documented that EFE increased degradation rate after 12 and 24 h of in vitro incubation, but not after 48 or 96 h (⁶). This is supported by other studies (⁷), reporting that EFE promote a fast degradation of some fraction of fiber, but have no activity upon the less degradable fraction. Accordingly, digestion rate increases within the first hours of incubation, then decreases until an asymptote (²⁰), given by lack of substrate (⁶) or inability of enzymes (whether exogenous or ruminal) to degrade that part of the fiber.

Adding EFE and LAB to the forage before ensiling, reduced digestibility of corn silage, particularly when used together. Stokes (1992) also reported this antagonistic effect between EFE and LAB when they are combined. Also, Lynch et al. (2015) reported that adding EFE alone or in combination with ferulic acid inoculant, did not improve corn silage fermentation or nutritional value, and even resulted in negative effects on these parameters.

In this study, neither EFE nor LAB alone, or their combination, showed a positive effect on corn silage quality. These results coincide with other studies on EFE alone (^{13, 19}), or combined with LAB (^{5, 24, 26}). However, more research should confirm these results. Gandra et al. (2017) concluded that the combination of EFE and LAB had a minimal synergistic effect on guinea grass silage quality when added to increase NDF digestibility and decrease silage proteolysis.

In line with previous reports (²¹), cutting height did not affect IVNDFD (P=0.15) in this study. Nevertheless, most studies do report differences in NDF digestibility. Wu and Roth (2005) observed a 6.7% increase in IVNDFD from 17 to 49 cm cutting heights, while Neylon and Kung Jr (2003) found that digestibility went from 48.7 to 51.5% from 12.7 to 45.7 cm cutting heights. The latter result was attributed to a lower NDF content in silage from corn cut at taller heights. According to Lewis et al. (2004), 66.1, 67.3 or 69.1% of IVNDFD occurred from 15, 30 or 46 cm height, respectively, in three corn hybrids harvested at 35% DM.

Total digestible nutrients (TDN)

An interaction CH x AD (P=0.008) occurred for TDN per hectare (TDN ha^-1) (figure 3).

For each cutting height bars with different letters are statistically different (P<0.05). C - control (distilled water only); F - Fibrozyme® (fibrolytic enzymes with xylanase activity); L - Sil-All® (bacterial inoculant for silage based on lactic acid bacteria); FL - mixture of Fibrozyme + Sil-All.

Figure 3. Total digestible nutrients (TDN) of corn silages treated with different additives (C, F, L, FL) at three cutting heights (CH).

Figura 3. Nutrientes digestibles totales (TND) de ensilados de maíz tratados con diferentes aditivos (C, F, L, FL) a tres alturas de corte.

The treatment FL12 showed the lowest TDN yield. At 25 cm, no differences were found between treatments, while at 42 cm, TDN was higher in C and L, but lower in F and FL. These data show that F negatively affected TDN ha-1. Moreover, cutting height affected nutrients yield by area reducing 24.5% when cutting height changed from 12 to 42 cm. This decrease is especially important in corn plants with reduced height, as in this study.

Conclusions

Corn silage quality was not affected by adding a bacterial inoculant or a fibrolytic enzyme. The combination of both, inoculant and enzyme, decreased corn silage quality by promoting greater content of cell wall fractions and decreasing dry matter digestibility. Silage quality was greater for the 42 cm cutting height, but this cutting height produced 37.3% less dry matter and 24.5% less nutrients yield. The authors recommend focusing on good practices when ensiling.

References

1. AOAC (Association of Official Agricultural Chemist). 2006. Official methods of analysis. 18th ed. AOAC International, Arlington. VA.

2. Arriola, K. G.; Kim, S. C.; Staples, C. R.; Adesogan, A. T. 2011. Effect of fibrolytic enzyme application to low- and high-concentrate diets on the performance of lactating dairy cattle. In Journal of Dairy Science. 94(2): 832-841. DOI: 10.3168/jds.2010-3424

3. Badhan, A.; Jin, L.; Wang, Y.; Han, S.; Kowalczys, K.; Brown, D.; Juarez A. C.; Latoszek-Green, M.; Miki, B.; Tsang, A.; McAllister, T. 2014. Expression of a fungal ferulic acid esterase in alfalfa modifies cell wall digestibility. In Biotechnology for Biofuels. 7(1): 39. DOI: 10.1186/1754-6834-7-39

4. Berone, G.; Bertrám, N.; Di Nucci, E. 2021. Forage production and leaf proportion of lucerne (Medicago sativa L.) in subtropical environments: fall dormancy, cutting frequency and canopy effects. Revista de la Facultad de Ciencias Agrarias. Universidad Nacional de Cuyo. Mendoza. Argentina. 53(1): 79-88. DOI: https://doi.org/10.48162/rev.39.008

5. Bureenok, S.; Langsoumechai, S.; Pitiwittayakul, N.; Yuangklang, C.; Vasupen, K.; Saenmahayak, B.; Schonewille, J. T. 2019. Effects of fibrolytic enzymes and lactic acid bacteria on fermentation quality and in vitro digestibility of Napier grass silage. In Italian Journal of Animal Science. 18(1): 1438-1444. DOI: 10.1080/1828051X.2019.1681910

6. Colombatto, D.; Mould, F. L.; Bhat, M. K.; Phipps, R. H.; Owen, E. 2004. In vitro evaluation of fibrolytic enzymes as additives for maize (Zea mays L.) silage II. Effects on rate of acidification, fibre degradation during ensiling and rumen fermentation. In Animal Feed Science and Technology. 111(1-4): 129-143. DOI: 10.1016/j.anifeedsci.2003.08.011

7. Colombatto, D.; Mould, F. L.; Bhat, M. K.; Owen, E. 2007. Influence of exogenous fibrolytic enzyme level and incubation pH on the in vitro ruminal fermentation of alfalfa stems. InAnimal Feed Science and Technology . 137(1-2): 150-162. DOI: 10.1016/j.anifeedsci.2006.10.001

8. Dehghani, M. R.; Weisbjerg, M. R.; Hvelplund, T.; Kristensen, N. B. 2012. Effect of enzyme addition to forage at ensiling on silage chemical composition and NDF degradation characteristics. In Livestock Science. 150 (1-3): 51-58. DOI: 10.1016/j.livsci.2012.07.031

9. Diepersloot, E. C.; Heizen, C. Jr.; Saylor, B. A.; Ferraretto, L. F. 2022. Effect of cutting height, microbial inoculation, and storage length on fermentation profile and nutrient composition of wholeplant corn silage. In Translational Animal Science. 6(2): 1-10. DOI: 10.1093/tas/ txac037

10. dos Santos, A. P. M.; Santos, E. M.; Silva de Oliveira, J.; Pinto de Carvalho, G. G.; Garcia Leal de Araújo, G.; Moura Zanine, A.; Martins Araújo Pinho, R.; Ferreira, D. de J.; da Silva Macedo, A. J.; Pereira Alves, J. 2021. Effect of urea on gas and effluent losses, microbial populations, aerobic stability and chemical composition of corn (Zea mays L.) silage. Revista de la Facultad de Ciencias Agrarias . Universidad Nacional de Cuyo. Mendoza. Argentina. 53(1): 309-319. DOI: https://doi.org/10.48162/rev.39.030

11. Eun, J. S.; Beauchemin; K. A.; Schulze, H. 2007. Use of exogenous fibrolytic enzymes to enhance in vitro fermentation of alfalfa hay and corn silage. In Journal of Dairy Science. 90(3): 1440-1451. DOI: 10.3168/jds.S0022-0302(07)71629-6

12. Ferraretto, L. F.; Shaver, R. D.; Luck, B. D. 2018. Silage review: recent advances and future technologies for whole-plant and fractionated corn silage harvesting. In Journal of Dairy Science. 101(5): 3937-3951. DOI: 10.3168/jds.2017-13728

13. Gallardo, I.; Bárcena, R.; Pinos-Rodríguez, J. M.; Cobos, M.; Carreón, L.; Ortega, M. E. 2010. Influence of exogenous fibrolytic enzymes on in vitro and in sacco degradation of forages for ruminants. InItalian Journal of Animal Science . 9(e8): 34-38. DOI: 10.4081/ijas.2010.e8

14. Gandra, J. R.; De Oliveira, E. R.; De Goes, R. H. T. B.; De Oliveira, K. M. P.; Takiya, C. S.; Del Valle, T. A.; Araki, H. M. C; Silveira, K.; Silva, D.; Da Silva Pause, A. G. 2017. Microbial inoculant and an extract of Trichoderma longibrachiatum with xylanase activity effect on chemical composition, fermentative profile and aerobic stability of guinea grass (Pancium máximum Jacq.) silage. In Journal of Animal and Feed Sciences. 26: 339-347. DOI: 10.22358/jafs/80776/2017

15. Getabalew, M.; Mindaye, A.; Alemneh, T. 2022. Silage and enzyme additives as animal feed and animals response. In Archives of Animal Husbandry & Dairy Science. 2(4): 1-6. DOI: 10.33552/AAHDS.2022.02.000543

16. INEGI (Instituto Nacional de Estadística y Geografía). 2017. Anuario estadístico y geográfico de Veracruz de Ignacio de la Llave 2017. INEGI, México. 1222 p. http://ceieg. veracruz.gob.mx/wp-content/uploads/sites/21/2018/04/AEGEV-2017.pdf (fecha de consulta: 21/08/2020).

17. Irawan, A.; Sofyan, A.; Ridwan, R.; Hassim, H. A.; Respati, A. N.; Wardani, W. W.; Sadarman, Astuti, W. D.; Jayanegara, A. 2021. Effects of different lactic acid bacteria groups and fibrolytic enzymes as additives on silage quality: A meta-analysis. In Bioresource Technology Reports. 14: 100654. DOI: 10.1016/j.biteb.2021.100654

18. Kolar, S.; Vranic, M.; Bozic, L.; Bosnjak, K. 2022. The effect of maize crop cutting height and the maturity at harvest on maize silage chemical composition and fermentation quality in silo. In Journal of Central European Agriculture. 23(2): 290-298. DOI: 10.5513/JCEA01/23.2.3504

19. Kung, L. Jr.; Treacher, R. J.; Nauman, G. A.; Smagala, A. M.; Endres, K. M.; Cohen, M. A. 2000. The effect of treating forages with fibrolytic enzymes on its nutritive value and lactation performance of dairy cows. In Journal of Dairy Science. 83(1): 115-122. DOI: 10.3168/jds.S0022-0302(00)74862-4

20. Kung, L. Jr.; Cohen, M. A.; Rode, L. M.; Treacher, R. J. 2002. The effect of fibrolytic enzymes sprayed onto forages and fed in a total mixed ratio to lactating dairy cows. In Journal of Dairy Science. 85(9): 2396-2402. DOI: 10.3168/jds.S0022-0302(02)74321-X

21. Kung, L. Jr.; Moulder, B. M.; Mulrooney, C. M.; Teller, R. S.; Schmidt, R. J. 2008. The effect of silage cutting height on the nutritive value of a normal corn silage hybrid compared with Brown midrib corn silage fed to lactating cows. In Journal of Dairy Science. 91(4): 1451-1457. DOI: 10.3168/jds.2007-0236

22. Lewis, A. L.; Cox, W. J.; Cherney, J. H. 2004. Hybrid, maturity, and cutting height Interactions on corn forage yield and quality. In Agronomy Journal. 96: 267-274. DOI: 10.2134/agronj2004.2670

23. Lynch, J. P.; OʼKiely, P.; Waters, S. M.; Doyle, E. M. 2012. Conservation characteristics of corn ears and stover ensiled with the addition of Lactobacillus plantarum MTD-1, Lactobacillus plantarum 30114, or Lactobacillus buchneri 11A44. In Journal of Dairy Science. 95(4): 2070-2080. DOI: 10.3168/jds.2011-5013

24. Lynch, J. P.; Baah, J.; Beauchemin, K. A. 2015. Conservation, fiber digestibility, and nutritive value of corn harvested at 2 cutting heights and ensiled with fibrolytic enzymes, either alone or with a ferulic acid esterase-producing inoculant. In Journal of Dairy Science. 98(2): 1214-1224. DOI: 10.3168/jds.2014-8768

25. Muck, R. E.; Nadeau, E. M. G.; McAllister, T. A.; Contreras-Govea, F. E.; Santos, M. C.; Kung, L. Jr. 2017. Silage review: recent advances and future uses of silage additives. In Journal of Dairy Science. 101(5): 3980-400. DOI: 10.3168/jds.2017-13839

26. Nair, J.; Yang, H. E.; Redman, A. A.; Chevaux, E.; Drouin, P.; McAllister, T. A.; Wang, Y. 2022. Effects of a mixture of Lentilactobacillus hilgardii, Lentilactobacillus buchneri, Pediococcus pentosaceus and fibrolytic enzymes on silage fermentation, aerobic stability, and performance of growing beef cattle. Translational Animal Science. 6(4): 1-12. DOI: 10.1093/tas/txac144

27. Neylon, J. M.; Kung, L. Jr. 2003. Effects of cut height and maturity on the nutritive value of corn silage for lactating cows. In Journal of Dairy Science. 86(6): 2163-2169. DOI: 10.3168/jds.S0022-0302(03)73806-5

28. NRC (National Research Council). 2001. Nutrient Requirements of Dairy Cattle. 7th rev. ed. Natl. Acad. Sci., Washington. DC.

29. Oliveira, A. S.; Weinberg, Z. G.; Ogunade, I. M.; Cervantes, A. A. P.; Arriola, K. G.; Jiang, Y.; Kim, D.; Li, X.; Gonçalves, M. C. M.; Vyas, D.; Adesogan, A. T. 2017. Meta-analysis of effects of inoculation with homofermentative and facultative heterofermentative lactic acid bacteria on silage fermentation, aerobic stability, and the performance of dairy cows. In Journal of Dairy Science. 100(6): 4587-4603. DOI: 10.3168/jds.2016-11815

30. Rebora, C.; Ibarguren, L.; Barros, A.; Bertona, A.; Antonini, C.; Arenas, F.; Calderón, M.; Guerrero, D. 2018. Corn silage production in the northern oasis of Mendoza, Argentina. Revista de la Facultad de Ciencias Agrarias . Universidad Nacional de Cuyo. Mendoza. Argentina. 50(2): 369-375. https://bdigital.uncu.edu.ar/12073.

32. Sheperd, A. C.; Kung, L. Jr. 1996. An enzyme additive for corn silage: Effects on silage composition and animal performance. In Journal of Dairy Science. 79(10): 1760-1766. DOI: 10.3168/jds.S0022-0302(96)76543-8

33. Silveira Pimentel, P. R.; dos Santos Brant, L. M.; Vasconcelos de Oliveira Lima, A. G.; Costa Cotrim, D.; Nascimento, T.; Lopes Oliveira, R. 2022. How can nutritional additives modify ruminant nutrition? InRevista de la Facultad de Ciencias Agrarias . Universidad Nacional de Cuyo. Mendoza. Argentina. 54(1): 175-189. DOI: 10.48162/rev.39.076

34. Singh, D.; Kumar-yadav, S.; Sharma, B.; Malik, T. A.; Kumari, V.; Hassan-Mir, S. 2018. Use of exogenous fibrolytic enzymes as feed additive in ruminants: A review. In International Journal of Chemical Studies. 6(6): 2912-2917.

35. Stokes, M. R. 1992. Effects of an enzyme mixture, an inoculant, and their Interaction on silage fermentation and dairy production. In Journal of Dairy Science. 75(3): 764-773. DOI: 10.3168/jds.S0022-0302(92)77814-X

36. Undersander, D.; Mertens, D.; Thiex, N. 1993. Forage analyses procedures. National Forage Testing Association. Omaha, NE 68137, USA. p. 139. https://fyi.extension.wisc.edu/ forage/files/2014/01/NFTA-Forage-Analysis-Procedures.pdf (Accessed November 2021).

37. Vallejo, L. H.; Salem, A. Z. M.; Kholif, A. E.; Elghangour, M. M. Y.; Fajardo, R. C.; Rivero, N.; Bastida, A. Z.; Mariezcurrena, M. D. 2016. Influence of cellulase or xylanase on the in vitro rumen gas production and fermentation of corn stover. In Indian Journal of Animal Sciences. 86(1): 70-74.

38. Yitbarek, M. B.; Tamir, B. 2014. Silage Additives: Review. In Open Journal of Applied Sciences. 4(5): 258-274. DOI: 10.4236/ojapps.2014.45026

39. Wallace, R. J.; Wallace, S. J.; Mckain, N.; Nsereko, V. L.; Hartnell, G. F. 2001 Influence of supplementary fibrolytic enzymes on the fermentation of corn and grass silages by mixed ruminal microorganisms in vitro. In Journal of Animal Science. 79(7): 1905-1916. DOI: 10.2527/2001.7971905x

40. Wu, Z.; Roth, G. 2005. Considerations in managing cutting height of corn silage. Penn State Cooperative Extension Bulletin DAS 03-72. Department of Dairy and Animal Science, Pennsylvania State University, University Park. 7 p. https://extension.psu.edu/considerations-in-managing-cutting-height-of-corn-silage (Accessed August 2020).